Kotler Galleries & Auctioneers

Wow! Such an easy and enjoyable process! We were greeted by Ron! He looked at everything: Sold my Gold & Silver - Very happy with offer! Paid more than any other pawnshop. Highly recommend to anyone! A++++++++++++

Sold my diamond ring they are the best in Long Island had a great experience with Ron & Ed!

The other day we had the most wonderful experience here. Edward was so good with us explaining everything. My wife and I left extremely happy and satisfied. We will definitely return. They have my highest recommendations. A+++++++++

Wow! What a great experience. All inspections are done right in front of you and weighed accordingly. Very happy service. A+

I just left here and was paid the highest price after shopping my gold and diamonds to other pawn shops. Edward was professional, personable, and kind! A++++++

This was my first time ever coming to Kotler's Jewelry & Loan and I have to say; the level of professionalism and kindness I received was impressive. I was surprised how easy and quick it was to sell my necklace, rings, etc.and getting cash is always nice! I would absolutely recommend them to anyone. A+++++++

I am so pleased with my experience at Kotler Galleries and Auctioneers. The minute I stepped into the store, I was greeted by a store representative who was so helpful and kind. It was my first time selling some jewelry, and the store representative walked me through the steps and explained everything to me. I was able to sell some jewelry and I also purchased the cutest ring for my daughter! Will definitely be coming back here!

Wonderful place! Edward was very thorough in explaining the process, testing jewelry and making sure you are comfortable during the entire process. I will be going back with some other items and I recommend them to friends and family. FIVE STARS!

I had an absolutely wonderful experience with Kotler Galleries. Edward is the most knowledgeable professional on antiques that I have ever met. Going to this store is like being a guest on Antiques Roadshow. It was like visiting one of the nation's experts on antiques and history. I have already referred 3 friends to the Kotlers. I would definitely return there again for their expert opinion to buy or sell precious items.

I would give KOTLER Jewelers 10 stars if I could! The two attendants at this place were phenomenal. They made me feel so comfortable and confident of what I was looking out for. They are so knowledgeable, super friendly and helpful! I can't even imagine ever going anywhere else apart from this place. They are so fun and so professional. 100% recommended!

Excellent service! We guessed at the value of our scrap silver and were quite surprised to hear the actual value. Masks and gloves made us feel safe as well.

Met with Ron and he was extremely nice and knowledgeable. Gave me the best price possible and was easy to work with. Definitely coming back! A+++

Wow, I cant believe this place. I found this store from the sign outside of BJs. I called first before I came and asked if a appointment was neccesary before I visited. They sounded nice when I called and said I could visit any time during their business hours to sell some unwanted gold and costume jewelry my aunt had left me. I should say before going there i checked with my local jewelry store in oceanside on how much i would get and showed me what was real and fake.

But they dumped everything back in the same bag. When I got to Kotler I dont know who the man behind the counter was with black hair but he made me feel very uncomftorable and proceeded to tell me things were just costume when in fact i knew they were gold from my previous visit and then he tried to give me a lot less then the jewelry store and before leaving said he could pay more for the costume jewelry and began increasing the price. What a slime ball. Please buyers and sellers be aware. When dealing with slimeballs like this place knowledge is power.

KOTLER'S is a class act-- Family friendly atmosphere, great service and good people. A+

Went in yesterday and asked the guys behind the counter if he had any empty little cardboard jewelry boxes, the cardboard ones with the fake foil, not the good velvet ones. He said he had to check, came back and put a tiny one on the counter and asked me for $10. I have gotten these little boxes from jewelry stores on multiple occasions and have never been asked for more than a $1 or $2.

Anywhere online they are literally a few pennies. He told me $10 with a straight face. The face of an absolutely dishonest dirtbag. Tried to price gauge me to the hilt. This is not someone you should trust at all. I would recommend anyone local to the area to absolutely avoid this chop shop.

Saw it on Etsy, exactly as described and went in person to see it. Ron was informative, helpful, earnest and I will be a repeat spender as there are finds that are unique and appropriately priced. Ron is very knowledgeable about his merchandise and has a great eye for what you will not find elsewhere. Looking for remarkable then this is your place.

The two brothers are consummate professionals; they communicate well, and are really clear about the whole process. I took my jewelry to a few other places and was pleasantly surprised with their offer. Other shops, said come back. Our Gemologist is off on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday's. LOL! Not these guys! Absolute pleasure!

Ron was a huge help in helping me pick out an antique artisan vase for my mother in law and with helping me choose an addition to my nephews comic collection! Recommended in my book

Edward was friendly, knowledgeable and very helpful; this was my first experience with selling my unwanted jewelry. I'm happy to say it was a great experience and a pleasure working with Kotler Galleries. I would recommend them to anyone!

True, unaltered email chain in inquiring about an item. "The pedestal table has been sold for more than the asking price. If you want something, buy it before its gone. Best Regards ThisArt Gallery" On one hand, maybe not the best judgment for a dealer who maintains a Twitter account. On the other, maybe he secretly wants you to know what a nightmare it will be dealing with him.